You’d never in a million years start a bonfire in your guest bedroom and stoke it with a wad of hundred-dollar bills. That’s just crazy—not to mention wasteful. But if you’re heating your home with a traditional HVAC system, that’s exactly what you’re doing, in a way. How to avoid this waste of energy and money? Try zone heating.
Gas fireplaces typically hook up to your home’s natural gas line or propane tank, which feeds burners in the unit to create what looks like a wood fire. Heat is distributed throughout the room by a built-in fan.
PROS: Extremely efficient; variety of models and styles to choose from
CONS: Cost of natural gas and propane is increasing; lacks the look and feel of a real wood fire
Wood inserts and wood-burning stoves use the same fan technology that’s incorporated into gas fireplaces to distribute heat throughout a room. But instead of distributing gas heat, it’s the heat from a contained, airtight wood fire.
PROS: Can’t beat the charm of crackling flames; fuel is cheap; easy to convert wood-burning fireplace into a zone heater with a wood insert
CONS: Not as efficient as similar gas models; higher maintenance (requires regular cleaning of stove and chimney, removal of ashes, lifting of logs) and messier
Much like the other zone-heating options, pellet stoves are available in a variety of styles and sizes, and the technology involved is surprisingly sophisticated. The stoves feature fans, but many have automatic starters and pellet feeders to keep you warm all day and night.
PROS: Pellets burn more cleanly and efficiently than wood; very little smoke; can sometimes burn other biomass, such as dried corn (check with your dealer before substituting fuel, though); only have to re-fuel once a day
CONS: Requires electricity to run parts (fan, controls, pellet feeder), so need a back-up power supply; no look and feel of a wood fire; mechanical parts are more prone to failure than gas or wood stove if not maintained properly
Radiant heating systems deliver heat to your home through a series of coiled tubes that circulate either electricity or hot water, with temperature controls that vary from zone to zone. Radiant heating systems typically are employed only on the first floors of homes, where the coiled water tubes can be embedded in concrete.
PROS: Energy efficient; improved air quality; even heat; quiet operation; flexible room layout (no air vents or bulky appliances to take up space); lower thermostat settings increase boiler life
CONS: Up-front cost is high; can lose heat into the ground without sufficient insulation
Read the full story in the November/December 2006 issue of Timber Home Living.
Bensonwood Homes photo by Rich Frutchey